Picture a request for quotation of the kind that arrives every week: a special part, three attachments, a tight deadline. At your company it goes through sales, engineering and costing. A competitor on the other side of the world first has the same documents read by an open AI model that anyone can download for free. An hour later, he has written a clean technical query and named a price range.
This is not a report on a real case but a thought experiment. Yet every ingredient in it is available today. And it raises an uncomfortable question: if general intelligence costs almost nothing, what is the premium that German industrial companies charge for their expertise still built on?
Intelligence becomes a commodity
First, the numbers. The cost of using a model at the level of GPT-3.5 fell more than 280-fold between November 2022 and October 2024 (Stanford AI Index). Epoch AI measured how fast the price falls for fixed levels of performance: between 9 and 900 times per year, depending on the task. For GPT-4's performance on PhD-level science questions it was 40 times per year (Epoch AI). The researchers point out themselves that the fastest drops were measured recently and that it is open whether they will last.
At the same time, open models are catching up. On some benchmarks, the gap between open and closed models shrank from 8 to 1.7 per cent within a year, and the gap between the best and the tenth-best model from 11.9 to 5.4 per cent (Stanford AI Index). The DeepSeek-R1 model showed that reasoning can be trained through pure reinforcement learning and passed on to smaller models; it was released openly and published in Nature (DeepSeek-AI).
In other words: the ability to understand a technical request, summarise a standard or write a query is no longer an edge. Anyone can have it, in Shenzhen as much as in Swabia.
The pressure comes from two sides
For German industrial companies, this meets a difficult situation. The Bundesbank finds that German export market shares have been shrinking since 2017. Machinery and the electrical industry were among the biggest contributors to the loss of competitiveness. Since 2019, the German export industry has tended to lose share with its main trading partners precisely where China gains (Bundesbank).
At home, costs are rising. Unit labour costs per person employed grew 4.8 per cent in 2025, well above the 3.2 per cent the European Commission had forecast on average for the member states. The Federal Statistical Office also describes China as an ever stronger competitor for German industrial goods; exports to China fell 11.9 per cent in 2025 (Destatis).
Higher costs at home, more competition abroad, and now a technology that gives the competitor the same reasoning power as you. If you justify your price with "we understand the technology better", the ground under you is shrinking.
What a model cannot download
So what remains? Not general intelligence, but your own history. Thirty years of test reports. The failure analysis that explains why a bearing fails earlier at one particular customer. The customer variant that only exists because in 2011 a machine stood in a damp hall. The reason why this tolerance is tighter than the standard requires.
None of this is in any public text. No model was trained on it, and none can download it. It sits in your own systems, folders and heads, often scattered and hard to find. That is the point: the raw material the competition lacks is lying unused in many companies.
This shifts the question of the moat. The moat is not the model you buy. Anyone else can buy the same model. The moat is the experience only you have, and the speed with which you make it usable.
Pricing power moves to speed and proof
If that is right, what customers pay for changes. Not for someone having understood the request. Soon any machine can do that. But for who answers the request, the change request or the service case correctly and fastest, with proof: this design rests on this test report, this recommendation on these three earlier cases.
This is not only true in sales. In service, the same question decides whether a machine runs again in the afternoon or only after a technician's visit next week. In engineering, it decides whether a mistake from 2016 is made a second time. In all these places, what counts is not how clever an answer sounds, but whether it is right and where it comes from.
An industrial company that can search its own history in minutes answers faster and more precisely than a competitor who only has a model's public knowledge. It can justify its answer, and a justified answer supports a price.
Where you can start
The first step is not a technology decision but an inventory. Which twenty technical questions do your customers ask most often? Where does the answer to each of them live today: in which system, which folder, whose head? And how long does it take until someone finds it and can prove it?
If you answer these three questions honestly, you usually see two things. First, many answers already exist; they just can't be found. Second, the time to an answer depends on a few people who have everything in their heads and are therefore interrupted all the time. This is where the edge appears that an open model cannot hand to your competitor. It is not about having the smartest model. It is about finding your own knowledge faster than anyone else.
Our assessment
An assessment, not a fact: by 2027, the gap between the best open and the best closed model will no longer decide any industrial purchase. Instead, tenders will compare suppliers on how fast and how traceably they answer technical questions.
The good news for the Mittelstand: it already has the decisive raw material, in its own house. The bad news: it is only useful if you can find it.
Sources
- Stanford HAI, Apr 2025: The 2025 AI Index Report
- Epoch AI, 12 Mar 2025: LLM inference prices have fallen rapidly but unequally across tasks
- DeepSeek-AI, Nature, 22 Jan 2025: DeepSeek-R1: Incentivizing Reasoning Capability in LLMs via Reinforcement Learning
- Deutsche Bundesbank, 14 Jul 2025: What's behind the sustained decline in German export market shares?
- Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis), 15 Jan 2026: Bruttoinlandsprodukt 2025 für Deutschland (Statement zur Pressekonferenz)
